Employer Branding in a Crowded Job Market

It’s a difficult job market for everyone. There are fewer vacancies but more applications.

The issues for prospective employees are too few opportunities and the dilemma of whether they should throw their hats into the ring.

Businesses aren’t struggling to attract volume – they’re struggling to manage it, to identify quality, and to oversee their internal culture.

This means that the employer branding landscape is changing.

This post will guide you through this evolving landscape and help you understand how it influences transparency, perception, and reputation.

1. Current challenges

  • An oversupply of applicants, including many who are overqualified
  • Candidate frustration and burnout leading to cynicism or mistrust
  • A risk of undervaluing internal culture or long-term employee fit
  • Employer brands under scrutiny from distressed jobseekers and cautious internal stakeholders.

2. The roles of Clarity, Transparency, and Respect

Clarity
  • Being clear about what roles truly involve, what success looks like and values alignment
  • Precision in job descriptions, EVP messaging, and employer brand tone of voice.
Transparency
  • Acknowledge the current environment without seeking to exploit it.
  • Be upfront about challenges, expectations and career pathways
  • Recognise that authentic brands are more valuable during uncertain times.
Respect
  • Think beyond the applicant: how do you demonstrate care, dignity, and acknowledgement towards all candidates?
  • Acknowledge that your employer brand is shaped by how you say no, not just how you recruit.
  • Make people feel valued, even if they don’t get an interview, let alone a job.

3. What an effective Employer Brand looks like in this market

  • Human, humble tone of voice – not self-congratulatory
  • Career pathways that speak to both entry-level and experienced applicants
  • Genuinely inclusive language – not just performative diversity
  • Employer storytelling grounded in everyday reality, not jargon.

4. Mistakes to avoid

  • Overplaying your hand – coming across as too self-important due to an applicant surplus
  • Ghosting or generic rejections – harming long-term brand reputation.
  • Failing to involve internal staff as brand ambassadors – they remain your strongest proof.

5. Tactics for today

  • Refresh your careers page to speak to today’s job market
  • Create a strong, respectful rejection template that reinforces your brand tone
  • Profile recent hires who selected your company for specific values or growth opportunities.
  • Train hiring managers to communicate brand messages consistently
  • Conduct a quick micro-audit: how does your process feel to someone applying right now

6. Tactics for tomorrow

  • Treat your employer brand as a strategic asset – link it to business planning, ESG, and leadership.
  • Review your EVP and create an employer brand story which showcases what you stand for.
  • Shift your recruitment focus from attraction to selection, so it becomes more about filtering quality than filling a role.
  • Reassess your current employer brand, including strategy, assets, execution, and measurement.

Our next blog will focus on the personality of your employer brand, which:

  • Shows how you show up as an employer
  • Shapes how people experience your culture and values
  • Helps you stand out in a competitive job market
  • Builds emotional connections
  • Attracts the right cultural fit
  • Increases employee advocacy and retention.

If you're uncertain about how well your employer brand is performing, we offer a quick, focused audit that will deliver an assessment anda staged course of action.

More

October 2025
Plus icon
Employer Branding in a Crowded Job Market
It’s a difficult job market for everyone. There are fewer vacancies but more applications. The issues for prospective employees are too few opportunities and the dilemma of whether they should throw their hats into the ring.
Read more →
July 2024
Plus icon
AI-generated images and the importance of brand transparency
Tradie Magazine recently faced criticism in the New Zealand subreddit for using AI-generated images without informing readers.
Read more →
June 2024
Plus icon
The Role of Brand in Creating Award-Winning Tenders
In the fiercely competitive world of tenders, standing out from the crowd requires more than just a strong proposal; it demands a robust strategy, a compelling idea and impeccable design.
Read more →
May 2024
Plus icon
Branding When Times Get Tough
There is no shortage of data, debate, and discourse telling us that times are tough.
Read more →
March 2024
Plus icon
Banking on trust: Our 5-minute design tweak to save $200M
Following Parliament’s Finance and Expenditure Committee inquiry into banks’ processes and consumer protections against scams, Commerce Minister Andrew Bayly has ordered banks to develop a voluntary reimbursement scheme for scammed customers.
Read more →
If you have an idea, vision or a project, we can help.
Get in touch →